Top 10 collectors items, in your opinion

We had a little discussion in another thread, about collectibles. And it made me think what you guy saw as the top 10 collectible shirts?

My 10 all time collectors items would probably be... I'll for sure forget some, and i'm leaving out variants...
1. Holy ship
2. Jokester
3. GiD New Era hat
4. Silver Air Johnny
5. 1st round boston exclusive New Era (Navy/Red/White)
6. Peekaboo colab
7. GiD Day of the Dead-ssert
8. Primary colors xbones sample shirt
9. Leg Lamp
10. Ugly Xmas crewneck

Wow I switched them around alot to make that list :S And as other shirts get mentioned, I'll probably have to mix it up again

If you have any of these in a large, would be happy to take all of these off your hands, so PM me

Mine would have to be

1. Back to the kitchen
2. Blue/pink air johnny
3. Red/grey air johnny
4. Sharky
5. Crossbone Buster
6. MV Sharky
7. BK Beetle Juice
8. Coo coo clock(i think thats the name lol)
9. Legalize Cupcakes
10. Jurassic Cakes

Surely Goonies should make the list? Popularity and value of shirts goes through stages, but it's probably the most consistant 'wanted list' shirt. Then in no particular order: BTTF (numbered), TMNT, Karate Cakes (numbered), Silver Air Johnny, Newbury Comics, MV Jaws, Jokester, Malfi Club and of course the Staff Shirt.

BTTF Crossbones
Goonies
Batcakes
Joker
JC x NB Crossbones
Malfi Club
Death For Desserts (GITD)
Primary Colors (shirt)
Stay Puft
Ugly Christmas Crew Neck

Off the top of my head....

You guys think the GID day of desserts is that rare? I never thought it was

I would put the a-ok shirt on the list as well. You never see that shirt and I think only 3 ppl have it on complete set.

Mine is what I personally think is the top 10 for me. It isn't the top 10 collectibles for everybody.

Let's try and make a top 10 rarest shirts and a top 10 rarest shirts you could buy.

1. Any Employee shirt (just put all in the same, otherwise it would take up most of the list)
2. Malfi club color variant. (one of a kind, owned by Kellen who works for JC)
2. Color variant of Gold boombox (silver boom box) (1 of a kind I think)
3. Color variant of Day of dead-sserts (1 of a kind I think)
4. Sailor crossbones color variant (1 of a kind I think)
5. Bike shirt with horn and dice set (1 of a kind I think)
6. Marcher Gold tooth (1 or 2 of a kind I think)
7. Suitcase tour suitcase Bill Cosby variant (a couple of this exists - Justin Bieber has this one )
8. Coffin tour headless horseman color variant (I don't know how many where made)
9. Coffin tour skeleton peace sign color variant (I don't know how many where made)
10.

Help me out with the rest of the list...

Shirts people could actually buy, would be something like (again I have to limit the list to none vintage shirts)

1. Primary colors xbones shirt (10 made)
2. Ugly Xmas sweater Crewneck (12 made)
3. A-OK (banned) (unknown amount might belong further up on the list)
4. Indian headdress (banned) (unknown amount might belong further up on the list)
5. Indian Big Kid (banned) (unknown amount might belong further up on the list)
6. Underground t-shirt (banned) (unknown amount might belong further up on the list)
7. Rubicks cube (banned) (unknown amount might belong further up on the list)
8. Malfi Club (50 made)
9. Johnny presents exclusive shirts (60 made)
10.

Which are wrong and which are missing?

I have the one of a kind day of the deadssert!!

Tattooed_Seagull wrote:I have the one of a kind day of the deadssert!!

I know

Tattooed_Seagull wrote:I have the one of a kind day of the deadssert!!

Which you should sell to me.

Anders...I'd say next are the #60 movie shirts BTTF and Karate Cakes. Just my opinion though...I've rarely seen them for sale.

I love it. The colorway is awesome.

i think firecracker should be on here only 100 made and the packaging was awesome

Jack_the_Bandit wrote:Anders...I'd say next are the #60 movie shirts BTTF and Karate Cakes. Just my opinion though...I've rarely seen them for sale.

You are probably right, I'll put them on there

I'm not sure if any other shirt is numbered below 100. Maybe the SITCM giveaways I know they are unnumbered but limited to 100. Or maybe an anniversary shirt? I have no idea what could be last.

Big kid Indian, underground and Rubicks cube are all super easy to get hold of even though they were banned, I don't think they should be on there.

wait, that Bill Cosby suitcase tour shirt is wicked rare? I legit gave mine away because I felt weird having it say straight edge on it.

TheMichness wrote:wait, that Bill Cosby suitcase tour shirt is wicked rare? I legit gave mine away because I felt weird having it say straight edge on it.

Not wicked rare lol, but a lot harder to find than the regular version

Jack_the_Bandit wrote:You guys think the GID day of desserts is that rare? I never thought it was

I would put the a-ok shirt on the list as well. You never see that shirt and I think only 3 ppl have it on complete set.

I have the "A-OK" shirt! The reason it is so rare rare is because it was discontinued due to the design looking similar to a gang symbol, or so I heard. Any discontinued items are going to be pretty rare.

todd_wrx wrote:Big kid Indian, underground and Rubicks cube are all super easy to get hold of even though they were banned, I don't think they should be on there.

This is true. I think it is because they were sold for a pretty long time before banned. The most recent discontinued item was the "Goin' Bananas" shirt, which presumably was removed from the store at the request of Chiquita.

garydarna wrote:

todd_wrx wrote:Big kid Indian, underground and Rubicks cube are all super easy to get hold of even though they were banned, I don't think they should be on there.

This is true. I think it is because they were sold for a pretty long time before banned. The most recent discontinued item was the "Goin' Bananas" shirt, which presumably was removed from the store at the request of Chiquita.

I wouldn't call these "super easy" to get a hold of.

igotchills wrote:

garydarna wrote:

todd_wrx wrote:Big kid Indian, underground and Rubicks cube are all super easy to get hold of even though they were banned, I don't think they should be on there.

This is true. I think it is because they were sold for a pretty long time before banned. The most recent discontinued item was the "Goin' Bananas" shirt, which presumably was removed from the store at the request of Chiquita.

I wouldn't call these "super easy" to get a hold of.

A-ok is super rare, but goin' bananas isn't (yet) but that is also because more people buy the shirt right away now, and they are printed in larger numbers. A-ok was when JC wasn't as popular as now, so naturally not as many where sild, and even fewer are still around. That probably won't be the case with Goin' bananas. I Think alot of people anticipated that it would get banned, and therefor bought it. So it will probably never be hard to get...

andersbusk wrote:

igotchills wrote:

garydarna wrote:

todd_wrx wrote:Big kid Indian, underground and Rubicks cube are all super easy to get hold of even though they were banned, I don't think they should be on there.

This is true. I think it is because they were sold for a pretty long time before banned. The most recent discontinued item was the "Goin' Bananas" shirt, which presumably was removed from the store at the request of Chiquita.

I wouldn't call these "super easy" to get a hold of.

A-ok is super rare, but goin' bananas isn't (yet) but that is also because more people buy the shirt right away now, and they are printed in larger numbers. A-ok was when JC wasn't as popular as now, so naturally not as many where sild, and even fewer are still around. That probably won't be the case with Goin' bananas. I Think alot of people anticipated that it would get banned, and therefor bought it. So it will probably never be hard to get...

This is why you're a CompleteSet curator, you are an expert my friend!

Also the bananas shirt was out for quite a bit longer than the a-ok.

andersbusk wrote:

igotchills wrote:

garydarna wrote:

todd_wrx wrote:Big kid Indian, underground and Rubicks cube are all super easy to get hold of even though they were banned, I don't think they should be on there.

This is true. I think it is because they were sold for a pretty long time before banned. The most recent discontinued item was the "Goin' Bananas" shirt, which presumably was removed from the store at the request of Chiquita.

I wouldn't call these "super easy" to get a hold of.

A-ok is super rare, but goin' bananas isn't (yet) but that is also because more people buy the shirt right away now, and they are printed in larger numbers. A-ok was when JC wasn't as popular as now, so naturally not as many where sild, and even fewer are still around. That probably won't be the case with Goin' bananas. I Think alot of people anticipated that it would get banned, and therefor bought it. So it will probably never be hard to get...

I've been collecting since 05' and don't need a huge explanation of something I already know dude! What I'm saying that people were calling banned shirts "super easy" to get while I wouldn't know any place to get them now besides ebay/here if somebody happens to be selling it in your size. I haven't been seeing many people selling many of these banned shirts on here so I would call those kinda hard to get for not a lot of $$$.

cody.raponi wrote:i think firecracker should be on here only 100 made and the packaging was awesome

I agree, that one is definitely rare and hardly ever for sale.

1. Firecracker (I paid 200 for and love the packaging)
2. Holy Ship (Also paid to much for)
3. Stay Puft (took me a year to get)
4. Karate Cakes numbered of course (want)
5. A-OK (never have seen this for sale and absolutely love it)
6. Malfi Club (Scotty will eventually get my money for this shirt)
7. Sliver numbered air jordan (only have seen in womans and smaller guys sizes)
8. MV key crossbones unnumbered limited to 100 summer 2012(haven't seen it for sale much)
9. TNMT shirt (maybe one day will give Scotty money for this as well)
10. Jokester even though there are plenty out there all the time

Jarvis1901 wrote:1. Firecracker (I paid 200 for and love the packaging)
2. Holy Ship (Also paid to much for)
3. Stay Puft (took me a year to get)
4. Karate Cakes numbered of course (want)
5. A-OK (never have seen this for sale and absolutely love it)
6. Malfi Club (Scotty will eventually get my money for this shirt)
7. Sliver numbered air jordan (only have seen in womans and smaller guys sizes)
8. MV key crossbones unnumbered limited to 100 summer 2012(haven't seen it for sale much)
9. TNMT shirt (maybe one day will give Scotty money for this as well)
10. Jokester even though there are plenty out there all the time

With 6, hasn't Scotty listed it for sale on the facebook page?

yes, he knows ive wanted it, everytime I go to buy it some accessory such as the godzilla scarf and the ebay auction for the jc skateboard by bordo bello as taking my funds.

garydarna wrote:

Jack_the_Bandit wrote:You guys think the GID day of desserts is that rare? I never thought it was

I would put the a-ok shirt on the list as well. You never see that shirt and I think only 3 ppl have it on complete set.

I have the "A-OK" shirt! The reason it is so rare rare is because it was discontinued due to the design looking similar to a gang symbol, or so I heard. Any discontinued items are going to be pretty rare.

I was lucky enough to recently pick this shirt up in men's XL. I got it for an absolutely sick price. I love it!

igotchills wrote:

andersbusk wrote:

igotchills wrote:

garydarna wrote:

todd_wrx wrote:Big kid Indian, underground and Rubicks cube are all super easy to get hold of even though they were banned, I don't think they should be on there.

This is true. I think it is because they were sold for a pretty long time before banned. The most recent discontinued item was the "Goin' Bananas" shirt, which presumably was removed from the store at the request of Chiquita.

I wouldn't call these "super easy" to get a hold of.

A-ok is super rare, but goin' bananas isn't (yet) but that is also because more people buy the shirt right away now, and they are printed in larger numbers. A-ok was when JC wasn't as popular as now, so naturally not as many where sild, and even fewer are still around. That probably won't be the case with Goin' bananas. I Think alot of people anticipated that it would get banned, and therefor bought it. So it will probably never be hard to get...

I've been collecting since 05' and don't need a huge explanation of something I already know dude! What I'm saying that people were calling banned shirts "super easy" to get while I wouldn't know any place to get them now besides ebay/here if somebody happens to be selling it in your size. I haven't been seeing many people selling many of these banned shirts on here so I would call those kinda hard to get for not a lot of $$$.

At the risk of telling you something else you already know, its also got a lot to do with those colourways being reasonably average that they rarely go over $40-$50 and I see Indian and Rubicks in mens sizes all the time. Underground not so much but it's easy to get hold of if you know how, and there's still not a huge demand for it.